The covered hen is the most reproduced object in American glass, and that is the whole problem. The shape has not changed since the 1880s. The question at the thrift-store shelf is never whether it is a hen on nest. It is which factory, which decade, and whether the lid you are holding was born with the base underneath it.
The short version
- Fifty makers, a hundred and forty years. Atterbury and Challinor, Taylor of Pittsburgh were pressing these in the 1880s. Westmoreland, Fenton, Indiana, Imperial, L.E. Smith and Kemple carried the form through the twentieth century, and Mosser is still pressing it from old molds today.
- Read the tail first. A flat tail pointing straight back, with a small circle molded on the hen's back, is Indiana Glass, and Indiana is most of what you will find. Split, curved tails belong to Fenton, Westmoreland and the older makers.
- Westmoreland is the weight. Dense, cold, satin-smooth glass with a red-painted comb. The WG monogram dates from 1946 on, but the company used paper labels for decades and plenty of real pieces are unmarked.
- Fenton hens are unmarked before the early 1970s. The oval logo you are hunting for was not molded into these until then. No mark tells you almost nothing.
- Check the lid before the mark. Marriages, a top from one dish on the base of another, are everywhere, and they take most of the value with them. The lid should sit flush all the way around with no rock.
- Common hens are ten-dollar objects. Social media has inflated asking prices; sold comps have not moved nearly as much. The money is in Atterbury with its glass eyes, Westmoreland's colored glass and slag, and the odd Indiana color.
Where the shape comes from
Covered dishes shaped like animals are older than pressed glass. Chinese porcelain makers had been at it for centuries, and Staffordshire and Dresden sold ceramic hens to American buyers from roughly 1790 to 1820 at prices only the well-off could manage. Pressed glass, which arrived in the late 1820s, is what turned the hen dish from a luxury into a kitchen object, and the first American glass versions appear around the 1860s as cheaper stand-ins for the European porcelain.
The Pittsburgh factories are the ones with a paper trail. Atterbury & Company and Challinor, Taylor & Company were both making hen dishes by the late 1880s, alongside Central Glass, which is thought to have made its mostly frosted hens around 1875, the Boston & Sandwich Glass Company, which closed in 1888, and McKee. Thomas B. Atterbury was a serial patentee of covered animal dishes, taking out patents on a rabbit in 1886, the famous duck in 1887 and a lion and a fox in 1889, and one of his glassworkers later recalled being sent to the zoo to look over the animals once the barnyard had been used up. The hen, though, carries no patent date. Atterbury never put one on a hen dish, which is why an "1880s" attribution on a hen rests on the glass eyes and the mold work, not on a molded date.
By Shirley Smith's count, the collector whose research underpins most serious writing on the form, fifty companies are known to have made hen on nest dishes and another forty are possible, in 191 distinct sizes or forms, from under two inches to eight inches long. They were made in England, France, Germany, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Finland, Spain, Italy, Portugal, Japan, Taiwan and China. A hen with no mark is not automatically American, and it is not automatically old.
Four words that are not the same thing
Sellers use "reproduction," "reissue" and "replica" interchangeably. They are not interchangeable, and the difference is most of the price. Smith's framework is the one to use.
| Term | What it means | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Original | Made by a company from a mold of its own design. | Atterbury, Central, Sandwich, Vallerysthal, Indiana |
| Reissue | The same company making the same piece again, sometimes decades apart. "Made by Westmoreland" does not tell you the decade. | Westmoreland, Imperial, Fenton |
| Reproduction | A later company buys the original mold and presses new glass from it. The mold is real; the era is not. Usually told apart by color, and the old owner's mark may still be in the glass. | Mosser, Rosso, Summit and Boyd, all working Westmoreland and other molds |
| Replica | A brand-new mold cut to look like another company's hen. Small details and color give it away. | L.G. Wright's copy of the McKee rooster; the recent Asian copies of the Indiana hen |
Molds also travel. A single mold can be copied, sold, modified, sold again and run by a company that never had the rights to it, which is why "from the original mold" is a weaker claim than it sounds unless you know who owned the mold the year your hen was pressed.
Start with the tail
This is the fastest read in the category, and it sorts out the majority of what you will see. An Indiana Glass hen has a flat tail pointing straight back from the head, never split or divided, and a small molded circle on its back. That circle is not a logo. A former plant manager explained it as a valve mark, the point where the automated press lifted the glass out of the mold. Once you have seen the flat tail you cannot unsee it.
Indiana made this one hen, about seven inches end to end, from roughly 1935 until the factory's last years in 1998 or 1999, which is a very long time for one mold and explains why so many survive. The base dates it. Smooth-rim bases are the earlier run, probably from the mid-to-late 1950s; the striated, pebbly "straw nest" base came in around 1972 or 1973. The first hens were clear glass; colors arrived from the mid-1960s, and some twenty-two are documented, including blue, marigold, green and aqua carnival finishes from the 1970s. Indiana never made a two-tone hen. A flat-tailed hen with a colored comb on a different-colored body is one of the recent Asian copies, stained or flashed with paint over the glass.
Every other major maker split the tail. Fenton's is smoothly curved with no feathered notches or scallops along the edge. Westmoreland's has a rounder tip. L.G. Wright's seven-inch hen has a scalloped rear edge. The old Atterbury and Challinor hens have the most detailed tails of all, which is part of why they read as older at a glance.
Then the weight and the white
Westmoreland made milk glass at Grapeville, Pennsylvania, from 1889 to May 1984, and claimed the first American milk glass sitting hen. Its glass is the densest in the category: cold, heavy for its size and satin-smooth, with a red-painted comb on the classic white version and a basketweave nest. The hens came in a small size a little over five inches and a large one around seven and a half, and in colors, including cobalt, amber, cranberry and marbled slag, that bring far more than the white.
The marks are where people go wrong. Westmoreland used a W inside a keystone from about 1910 into the 1940s, then the intertwined W and G from 1946 on, then a circled "Westmoreland" after David Grossman bought the factory in 1981. It also used paper labels from about 1906, on pieces that otherwise carry nothing. So a WG monogram puts a hen after 1946 but no closer, and no mark at all is compatible with a perfectly real Westmoreland hen.
Fenton, of Williamstown, West Virginia, is the other name that carries weight. Its eight-inch hen top, mold number 5199, has been in use since 1952 on three successive bases; the five-inch hen, number 5186, arrived in 1967 and stayed in production. The eight-inch hen is a Fenton copy of the Atterbury design with one telling change: Atterbury's slotted glass eyes became big, round, bulging eyes with no detail. Both Fenton sizes show six eggs around the body. And the fact that catches people: Fenton did not mold its oval logo into these hens until the early 1970s. The 1950s and 1960s pieces collectors want most are unmarked.
Carnival Westmoreland, and who it was really for
Westmoreland returned to iridescent glass in 1974 and kept at it until the doors closed in 1984, with much of the run made to order for Levay Glass of Edwardsville, Illinois. Smith's note on the hens is worth memorizing: the original Westmoreland five-inch hens were not made in carnival at all, and most of the company's carnival hen dishes were Levay pieces from the 1970s and early 1980s. A small carnival hen sold as "early Westmoreland" is being sold with the wrong decade attached.
Check the lid belongs
Every hen dish is two pieces, and the two pieces get separated. A marriage is a lid from one dish sitting on the base of another, and it is the most common problem in the category because the parts look like they should fit. Sometimes they nearly do. Smith measures both top and base from outside rim to outside rim, and notes that a Challinor top will not sit on an Atterbury base; it is a hair too large. Fenton collectors see Westmoreland tops on Fenton bases regularly, given away by the rounder tail tip, different egg sizes and placement, and a beaded rim with a crisscross side design where the Fenton base has none.
You do not need calipers at a garage sale. Set the lid on the base and run a fingertip around the seam; it should sit flush the whole way. Rock it gently. Any gap, any wobble, and you are looking at two dishes pretending to be one. Then compare the color of top and base in daylight. Two whites from two factories are rarely the same white.
Reading one on the shelf
- Tail. Flat and straight back with a circle on the back is Indiana. Split and curved is everyone else, and the shape of the split narrows it further.
- Comb and eye. Crisp points and a defined eye mean a good mold and an early pull from it. Soft, rounded detail means a worn mold or a copy of a copy. Inset glass eyes, when present and original, mean Atterbury.
- Lid fit. Flush all the way around, no rock, no gap, and the same white top and bottom.
- Nest texture. On an Indiana hen, smooth rim versus striated straw dates it to before or after about 1972. On the others, the weave pattern and rim treatment identify the base, which is half the dish.
- Weight. Westmoreland is dense and cold in the hand. Lightweight glass is usually later or foreign.
- Base wear. Real wear is scattered and uneven. A familiar old pattern with a pristine base is usually decades younger than it is pretending to be; wear that is perfectly even is usually applied.
- Marks, last. A mark narrows the date. The absence of one proves nothing.
Where people get burned
- Reproductions from real molds. After 1984 the Westmoreland molds went to Summit, Mosser, Rosso and Fenton. A pattern-perfect Westmoreland hen can have been pressed last year. Weigh color, wear and glass quality together, never the pattern alone.
- The Kemple story. Kemple hens have long been sold as "from original McKee molds," which is how the Kemples themselves described them. Smith argues the claim strains belief for all but possibly one five-inch split-rib base. Buy a Kemple as a Kemple.
- Labels. A paper label is evidence, not proof. Labels come off one dish and go onto another, and they have for a hundred years.
- Two-tone "Indiana" hens. Indiana never made one. The stained and flashed imports are the most common fake in the category right now.
What they are worth, honestly
Hen dishes had a moment on social media, and asking prices followed. Sold prices followed a good deal less. Glass Bottle Marks, which has tracked the Indiana hen longer than anyone, puts the common colors, white, clear, amber and olive, in the $3 to $15 range historically and notes the recent rise is hype-driven and unstable. Treat the $250 candy-dish headlines as a warning about listings, not a description of the market.
| Piece | What it tends to bring |
|---|---|
| Indiana Glass, common colors | $10 to $30 on a good day. Blue, green and aqua carnival from the 1970s reach $80 to $300; a scarce color such as cobalt is the one Indiana hen that can run into the hundreds. |
| Westmoreland, white milk glass | $25 to $75, more for the large seven-and-a-half-inch hen with the comb paint intact. |
| Westmoreland, colored or slag | Roughly $85 to $250 depending on color; cobalt, cranberry and slag at the top. |
| Fenton, 1950s and 1960s unmarked, or later iridescent hand-painted | $50 to $500, with the painted iridescent pieces at the high end. |
| Atterbury, 1880s, with original glass eyes | $150 to $400 and up for rare colors with both eyes intact. |
| Vallerysthal, French, hand-painted, 1880 to 1920 | $80 to $300 and up. |
| Any marriage | A fraction of the above. Price it as a lid and a base, not a dish. |
Beyond maker, the same four things move the price every time. Color: white is the baseline and everything else sits above it. Condition: chips live on the comb, the tail tip and the base rim, and a fingernail finds them faster than an eye does. Completeness: the correct lid is most of the value. Size: the little salt-dip hens and the big serving hens both outrun the common middle.
Why it matters
The hen on nest is the rare antique that never stopped being made. That is a nuisance for attribution and a gift for collecting, because it means the whole history of American pressed glass, from Pittsburgh in the 1880s through the milk glass boom of the 1950s to the carnival revival of the 1970s and the mold sales of the 1980s, sits on one thrift-store shelf in one shape, priced at a few dollars apiece. Learn the tail, the weight and the seam and you can read that shelf like a timeline. Skip them and you will pay Westmoreland money for a hen that was pressed in Ohio the year before last.
These get listed under a dozen names, "chicken dish," "covered hen," "glass rooster," and rarely under the maker. We built a free sourcing dashboard that searches seventeen vintage marketplaces at once and opens sold comps beside the live listings. Run the terms and see what surfaces.
Search "hen on nest" Search "Westmoreland hen" Search "Atterbury hen"Sources
- National Milk Glass Collectors Society — Shirley Smith, Hen on a Nest: Studying a Glass Collection — the history from porcelain to pressed glass, the early American makers and dates, the fifty-plus company and 191-form count, the original/reissue/reproduction/replica definitions, the Westmoreland carnival and Levay note, the Challinor-on-Atterbury fit, the Kemple argument, and the measuring method.
- Glass Bottle Marks — Indiana Glass Company Hen-on-Nest Dishes — the flat tail, the valve mark, the seven-inch size, the 1935 to late-1990s production span, base dating, the color list and carnival colors, the historical $3 to $15 range and the note on hype, and the two-tone Asian copies.
- Fenton Addict — Fenton Hen on Nest Features and Characteristics — Fenton mold numbers and dates, the Atterbury-derived eight-inch hen and its eyes, the split-tail description, the marking timeline, and the Westmoreland-on-Fenton marriage tells.
- Carnival Glass Worldwide — Westmoreland Carnival Glass Revival — the 1974 to May 1984 revival, the Levay commissions, Westmoreland's three marking methods, and the post-closure mold sales to Summit, Mosser, Rosso and Fenton.
- Know Old Stuff — Westmoreland Glass Value Guide — the 1889 to 1984 Grapeville dates, the keystone W, the WG monogram from 1946, paper labels from about 1906, the post-1981 mark, and the $85 to $250 range for colored hens.
- Collectors Weekly — Atterbury Designs for Covered Animal Dishes in Glass — Thomas B. Atterbury's patents of 1886 to 1889 and the zoo anecdote.
- Antiques Know How — 9 Valuable Vintage Hen-on-Nest Dishes — value ranges for Atterbury, Fenton, Vallerysthal, Westmoreland and Indiana carnival hens.
0 comments